How to Measure and Improve Change Failure Rate
It was a typical Monday morning, and the coffee machine was already working overtime. Our team gathered around the conference table, laptops open, and eyes still half-closed. We were preparing for our weekly retrospective, a ritual that had become second nature. But this time, something was different.
"Guys, our Change Failure Rate is through the roof!" exclaimed Sarah, our lead developer, with a mix of concern and curiosity.
Change Failure Rate (CFR) had become the ghost haunting our sprint retrospectives. Every time we thought we had it under control, it would sneak back in, causing failed deployments, late nights, and more caffeine consumption than we cared to admit. It was time to tackle this ghost head-on.
And that’s what led us down the rabbit hole of measuring and improving our CFR. What started as a daunting challenge turned into a journey of discovery, innovation, and—believe it or not—a bit of fun. And now, I’m here to share that journey with you.
Welcome to the DORA Metrics series! In today’s guide, we’ll dive deep into the world of Change Failure Rate, exploring what it is, why it matters, and how you can measure and improve it. But before we get started, let’s map out our adventure plan. 🗺️
What We’ll Cover Today
Here’s what’s on our agenda:
- 🤔 What is Change Failure Rate? – Understanding the basics of CFR.
- 📉 Why CFR Matters – Why you should care about this metric.
- 🧰 Measuring CFR – Tools and techniques to track your CFR effectively.
- 🔧 Strategies to Improve CFR – Practical tips to reduce your change failures.
- 🚀 Continuous Improvement – How to make lasting changes and keep CFR low.
🤔 What is Change Failure Rate?
Let’s start with the basics. Change Failure Rate is one of the four key metrics identified by the DevOps Research and Assessment (DORA) team to measure software delivery performance. Simply put, CFR is the percentage of changes—deployments, updates, patches—that result in a failure requiring a hotfix, rollback, or some other corrective action.
Think of it like this: if your software delivery is a game of bowling, each deployment is a roll. A strike is a successful deployment, but if you end up in the gutter, that’s a failure. CFR is the number of gutter balls you roll divided by the total number of rolls. The lower the number, the better your game.
📉 Why CFR Matters
So, why does CFR matter? Well, high CFR is a red flag for instability in your development process. It means that changes you’re making are frequently causing issues, which can lead to:
- Increased downtime – More time spent fixing problems means less time delivering new features.
- Decreased team morale – Constant failures can lead to burnout and frustration among your developers.
- Eroded customer trust – Frequent issues in production can cause users to lose confidence in your product.
In short, a high CFR can become a bottleneck that slows down your entire operation, making it crucial to measure and improve this metric.
🧰 Measuring CFR
Before we can improve something, we need to measure it. Tracking CFR isn’t rocket science, but it does require a bit of setup. Here’s how we did it:
1. Define What Constitutes a Failure 📏
First, you need to define what a "failure" means for your team. Is it any deployment that requires a rollback? Or does it include deployments that need a hotfix within 24 hours? Be clear about what you’re measuring to ensure consistency.
2. Use the Right Tools 🛠️
Automating the collection of CFR data is crucial. We used CI/CD tools like Jenkins and GitLab, which automatically track deployments and failures. By tagging deployments and their outcomes, we could easily calculate our CFR over time.
3. Set Up Dashboards 📊
To make the data meaningful, visualize it. We created dashboards using Grafana to track our CFR week by week. This allowed us to spot trends and correlate them with changes in our processes.
4. Analyze the Data 🔍
Look for patterns in your CFR data. Are failures clustered around certain types of changes? Do they happen more often at certain times of the day or week? Understanding these patterns is key to driving improvement.
🔧 Strategies to Improve CFR
Armed with our data, we set out to improve our CFR. Here’s what worked for us:
1. Improve Testing Coverage 🧪
It sounds obvious, but the more you test, the less likely you are to deploy a failure. We invested time in improving our automated test coverage, particularly for edge cases that were often the source of our failures. Unit tests, integration tests, and end-to-end tests all played a role in catching issues before they reached production.
2. Implement Feature Flags 🚩
Feature flags became our new best friend. By wrapping new features in flags, we could deploy them without activating them immediately. This allowed us to test features in production without affecting users, reducing the risk of failure.
3. Conduct Post-Mortems 🧠
Every failure became a learning opportunity. We conducted blameless post-mortems after each incident to understand what went wrong and how to prevent it in the future. The key here was "blameless"—we focused on the process, not the people, to foster a culture of continuous improvement.
4. Gradual Rollouts 🚀
We stopped deploying everything all at once. Instead, we moved to gradual rollouts, starting with a small percentage of users and scaling up as confidence grew. This approach limited the impact of any one failure and gave us time to react before a minor issue became a major problem.
5. Continuous Integration and Deployment 🏗️
By adopting CI/CD, we could deploy smaller, incremental changes more frequently. This not only reduced the complexity of each deployment but also made it easier to identify the root cause of any failures that did occur.
🚀 Continuous Improvement
Improving CFR isn’t a one-time fix; it’s a continuous process. Here’s how you can keep the momentum going:
- Regular Monitoring: Keep an eye on your CFR, and make it a key part of your sprint reviews. Regular monitoring ensures that you catch problems early and maintain focus on improvement.
- Team Buy-In: Ensure that everyone on your team understands the importance of CFR and is committed to improving it. This isn’t just a metric for managers—developers, testers, and ops all play a role.
- Iterative Adjustments: Don’t try to fix everything at once. Start with the most impactful changes, and iterate. Small, continuous improvements will lead to significant progress over time.
Wrapping It All Up
Our journey with Change Failure Rate was more than just a technical exercise—it was a transformative experience for our team. We learned to embrace data, take ownership of our processes, and celebrate our successes, no matter how small. CFR isn’t just about reducing failures; it’s about building a resilient, high-performing team that can deliver value to users consistently and confidently.
If you’re ready to take your development process to the next level, start by measuring your CFR, analyze the data, and make incremental improvements. The journey might not always be smooth, but I promise it will be worth it.
For more insights and resources to help you master DORA Metrics and beyond, be sure to visit ProductThinkers.com. Together, we can build better, more reliable software.
If you enjoyed this article and would like to support my work, consider buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com/rubenalap. Your support helps me create more content like this—thank you! ☕️